Research Article - (2016) Volume 6, Issue 4

Development of High Water Selective Sodium Alginate-Silica Hybrid Membranes via Sol-gel Technique for Pervaporation Dehydration of Ethanol

Shang Han, Shasha Na, Weixing Li* and Weihong Xing
College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing Tech University, Nanjing 210009, China
*Corresponding Author: Weixing Li, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Nanjing Tech University, Nanjing 210009, China, Tel: +86-25- 83172286, Fax: +86-25-83172292 Email:

Abstract

In order to improve the performance of sodium alginate (SA) membrane for dehydration of ethanol, a new method for preparing SA-silica membranes using sol-gel was proposed. The hybrid pervaporation membranes were prepared by hydrolysis and condensation of tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS) within SA aqueous solution. The obtained membranes were characterized by scanning electron microscope (SEM), energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX), Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Atomic Force Microscope (AFM), thermogravimetry (TG) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Then the membranes were tested by pervaporation dehydration of ethanol. FTIR indicated that -Si-O-C bonds were obtained. XRD showed the SiO2 particles were generated in the SA matrix. The thermal stability of hybrid membranes was enhanced after incorporating TEOS into SA from the DSC results. The tensile strength of SA-40 membrane was improved after incorporating TEOS into SA. The effect of mass ratio of TEOS to SA on the separation performance was investigated. The permeate flux was improved with increasing mass ratio of TEOS to SA. And the result showed that the permeate flux reached 274 g-m-2.h-1 with a high separation factor 17990 when the amount of water in feed was 10 wt% at 50°C. The Arrhenius apparent activation energy for permeation has been estimated from the temperature dependence of permeation values. The activation energy for permeation was 15.1 kJ/mol.

Keywords: Sodium alginate; Tetraethyl orthosilicate; Pervaporation; Ethanol; Dehydration

Introduction

Pervaporation (PV) has attracted growing interests in the separation process because of its energy-saving characteristics and high separation performance compared to traditional techniques [1,2]. It’s widely used in dehydration of ethanol, methanol and isopropanol. Sodium alginate (SA), a kind of polysaccharides extracted from seaweed, is considered as a prospective dehydration membrane material for its intrinsic properties such as good hydrophilicity, outstanding water solubility and good film-formation characteristics [3,4]. The development of SA membrane has been focused on for the decades. The performance of pure SA membrane is not so good to dehydrate organics. In order to improve the separation performance of SA membrane, modification methods such as blending, cross-linking and adding fillers have been applied. Dong et al. [5] blended SA with poly-(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) for separating ethanol aqueous solutions. The prepared membranes showed better pervaporation performance for ethanol aqueous solution with a permeate flux of 384 g-m-2.h-1 and a separation factor of 384 for 90 wt% ethanol aqueous solution at 45°C. Pan et al. [6] incorporated reduced grapheme oxide into SA matrix. The hybrid membranes exhibited optimum separation performance with a separation factor of 1566 and a permeate flux of 1699 g-m-2.h-1. Generally, metal oxides were added into the SA membrane for higher mechanical property and permeability. Organic-inorganic hybrid materials may be a proper candidate for having the advantages of organic moiety and inorganic moiety which have been recognized in various fields [7-9]. Inorganic particles have a good thermal stability as well as high mechanical strength. The separation performance of the membranes can be improved by incorporating inorganic particles into PV membranes [10-15]. Blending inorganic particles into polymer matrix is a simple way to prepare organic-inorganic hybrid membranes.

However, the inorganic particles often behave serious aggregation. In order to improve the dispersion performance of inorganic particles in casting membrane solution, in situ generation of inorganic particles via sol-gel method in polymer matrix is focused on. The generated inorganic particles can be dispersed in the organic membranes homogeneously. Kariduraganavar et al. [16] prepared chitosan based hybrid membranes by incorporating 2-(3, 4-epoxycyclohexyl) ethyltrimethoxysilane into chitosan matrix using a sol-gel technique. And the developed hybrid membranes could be effectively used to break the azeotropic point of water-isopropanol mixtures with separation selectivity of 17990 and a flux of 29.2 g-m-2.h-1 at 30°C for 10 mass% of water. Jiang et al. [17] incorporated TiCl4 into CS membrane, the membrane exhibited the optimal pervaporation performance with a permeate flux of 1403 g-m-2.h-1 and a separation factor of 730 for 90 wt% ethanol aqueous solution at 77°C. The sol-gel reaction is helpful to the hybridization of organic and inorganic components which can form covalent bonds and hydrogen bonds between the polymeric phase and inorganic phase [18-20]. Clearly, it is efficient to hybridize the organic and inorganic components homogeneously.

The aim of this work is to attempt preparation of a SA-silica hybrid membrane with high water selectivity via sol-gel technique for dehydration of ethanol. The proposed preparation method of the hybrid SA-silica membrane via sol-gel was rarely reported, and the latest report about hybrid membranes prepared by incorporating silica precursors into alginate matrix was study by Choudhari [21]. Here, we try to investigate the membrane preparation parameters and characterization of the separation characteristics for PV of ethanol solution.

Experimental

Materials

Sodium alginate, tetraethyl orthosilicate, ethanol (99.7%), glutaraldehyde solution (25%) and sulfuric acid were supplied by Sinopharm Chemical Reagent Co., Ltd. Deionized water was produced by a Milli-Q system (Millipore, US).

Membrane fabrication

The 3wt% SA solution was prepared by dissolving SA in deionized water with stirring for 3 h at 60°C. Then a known amount of TEOS was added to the SA solution. Subsequently, quantitative of glutaraldehyde and sulfuric acid were added into the mixtures which were used as cross-linking agent and catalyst, respectively. Then the solution was stirred for 24 h. After that the solution was cast onto an organic glass plate with the aid of automatic film blowing machine. Dried membranes were peeled off from the glass plate. The mass ratio of TEOS to SA was varied as 0, 10, 20, 30, 40 and 60%, and the resulting hybrid membranes were designated as SA, SA-10, SA-20, SA-30, SA-40 and SA-60.

Membrane characterization

The interaction properties among different chemical groups of the hybrid membranes were characterized by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) spectrometer (AVATAR360, Thermo Nicolet, USA). The morphologies of membranes were conducted with a fieldemission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) (S-4800, Hitachi, Japan). The silicon element was recorded by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) equipped on (FESEM). The crystalline structure of membrane was investigated using an X-ray diffraction (XRD) (Miniflex 600, Rigaku, Japan) in the range of 6-80° at the scan rate of 15° min-1. Tensile strength of the SA, SA-10, SA-20, SA-30, SA-40 and SA-60 matrix membranes were measured using the universal testing machine (CMT-6203, MTS SANS, China). Thermogravimetric (TG) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analysis were conducted by a thermoanalyzer (Sta 449 F3, Netzsch, Germany) at a heating rate of 10°C/min under nitrogen atmosphere to analysis the thermal stability of all membranes. The membrane thickness was determined by a field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) (S-4800, Hitachi, Japan). The increase in surface area and surface roughness was calculated by Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) (XE100, Park systems, Korea).

Swelling experiments

The dry membrane was weighed as Wd, and then it was immersed into 10wt% water-ethanol solutions for 24 h at room temperature to achieve equilibrium. The swollen membranes were taken out carefully and the solution on the membranes surface was wiped off by tissue paper, and then weighed as quickly as possible. The mass of the swollen membranes was measured as Ws (supplementary Table 1). The degree of swelling (DS) was calculated by the following Eq. (1).

image (1)

Where Wd and Ws are the mass of the dry and swollen membranes, respectively.

Pervaporation experiments

PV experiments were carried out using an indigenously designed apparatus. The feed temperature was controlled by constant temperature oil bath. The effective membrane area was 0.0011 m2. The permeated solution was condensed downstream by liquid nitrogen. A vacuum pump in the downstream maintained the pressure at about 300 Pa. The permeate flux was defined by Eq. (2).

image (2)

Where W represents the mass of permeate over a certain time interval t, A represents the effective membrane area.

The compositions of feed and permeate were determined by gas chromatograph (GC-2014, Shimadu, Japan) which was equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD). The length of PORAPAK® Q (mesh 50-80) column was 2 m. Helium (99.9999%) was used as the carrier gas. Both the injector and detector temperatures were 200°C and the column temperature was 180°C. The bridge current was 90 mA. The separation factor (α) was defined by Eq. (3).

(3)

Where XW, XE, YW and YE are the weight fractions of water and alcohol in the feed and permeate, respectively.

Results and Discussion

Membrane characterization

FTIR spectra analysis: Silanol groups were obtained by hydrolyzing TEOS. The silanol groups yielded siloxane bonds due to the dehydration or dealcoholysis reaction with other silanol or SA during the membrane drying [22]. Figure 1 shows the FT-IR spectra of SA membrane and hybrid membranes. A characteristic band at around 3243 cm-1 in SA pristine membrane spectra corresponds to -OH stretching vibrations. The peaks at 1591 cm-1 and 1406 cm-1 correspond to asymmetric and symmetric stretching of carboxyl group of SA, respectively. Peaks appeared at around 1010-1030 cm-1 are assigned to -C-O-C stretching of SA membrane. However, the intensity of these bands for the hybrid membranes increased which suggested the formation of -Si-O-C bonds [23]. That’s because -Si-O stretching also appears at the same wave numbers of -C-O stretching.

membrane-science-technology-membrane-hybrid-membranes

Figure 1: FT-IR spectra of SA membrane and hybrid membranes.

XRD analysis: The XRD patterns of SA membrane and hybrid membranes are shown in Figure 2. The SA membrane exhibited a broad peak around 13° [24], which is attributed to the presence of amorphous region in the polymer. After incorporating TEOS into SA matrix, broad peaks of SiO2 at around 21° appeared in hybrid membranes [25]. It’s clear that the generated SiO2 particle was in an amorphous form. The intensity of the SiO2 peaks increased gradually from SA-10 to SA-60 membrane with increasing mass ratio of TEOS to SA. This is because more SiO2 particles were generated upon increasing TEOS content.

membrane-science-technology-patterns-SA-hybrid-membranes

Figure 2: X-ray diffraction patterns of SA and hybrid membranes.

TG and DSC analysis: The thermal stability of the hybrid membranes was evaluated by TG and DSC under nitrogen flow. The results are shown in Figure 3. The membranes had three stages of weight loss from Figure 3a. The first weight loss of 20% occurred between ambient temperature and 200°C corresponds to the physically absorbed water molecules. The second thermal event occurring in the range of 200-250°C, which is attributed to the decomposition of SA matrix and the weight loss was about 25%. The third stage, for temperature higher than 250°C, corresponds to the residual decomposition reactions. What’s more, it can be clearly seen that the decomposition temperature of hybrid membranes were higher than the SA membrane in the DSC patterns (Figure 3b). It indicated that the thermal stability of membranes was virtually improved after hybridization, which is mainly due to a hindrance of chain mobility of SA by the generation of SiO2 and the hydrogen bonding between SA and SiO2.

membrane-science-technology-curves-hybrid-membranes

Figure 3: TG(a) and DSC(b) curves of hybrid membranes.

SEM and EDX characterizations: Figure 4 illustrates the SEM and EDX photographs of hybrid membranes. The surface view of SA membrane was smooth. But the surface of hybrid membranes became rougher with increasing mass ratio of TEOS to SA. From the EDX pictures, it can be seen that the SA membrane had no silicon element. However, the silicon element was obtained from the hybrid membranes, suggesting that the generation of SiO2 particles. This is agreement with the XRD results, because the formation of SiO2 particles was also verified by XRD analysis. The EDX Si-mapping of the SA-40 membrane in Figure 4e-3 showed that silicon element was distributed uniformly in the SA matrix which indicated the homogeneous hybrid structure.

membrane-science-technology-hybrid-membranes

Figure 4: SEM images of hybrid membranes: surface images of SA to SA-60 membranes (a-1, b-1, c-1, d-1, e-1,f-1); EDX of SA to SA-60 hybrid membranes (a-2, b-2, c-2, d-2, e-2,f-2,e-3(Si distribution)).

Tensile strength test: The maximum tensile strengths of all membranes are given in Table 1. The tensile strengths of SA, SA-10, SA-20, SA-30, SA-40 and SA-60 membrane were 26.8 MPa, 26.9 MPa, 16.8 MPa, 16.1 MPa, 28.8 MPa and 31.9 MPa, respectively. These data indicated higher mechanical strengths for the hybrid membranes expect SA-20 and SA-30 membrane as compared to SA membrane. The decrease of tensile strengths of SA-20 and SA-30 membranes may be because of the uniform dispersion in SA matrix as can be observed in the SEM images. The tensile strengths of the other membranes were improved by incorporating TEOS into SA matrix. It is due to the hydrogen and covalent bonds between SiO2 and SA.

Membrane Tensile strength (MPa)
SA 26.8
SA-10 26.9
SA-20 16.8
SA-30 16.1
SA-40 28.8
SA-60 31.9

Table 1: Mechanical strength data of SA and hybrid membranes.

Swelling behaviors

Membrane swelling plays a key role in separation property of the membrane which depends on the membrane structure. Figure 5 shows the effect of the mass ratio of TEOS to SA on the degree of swelling for hybrid membranes in 10wt% water-ethanol mixtures at 25°C. It can be seen that the degree of swelling was enhanced with increasing mass ratio of TEOS to SA. This is attributed to increased hydrophilic nature of the hybrid membranes owing to the presence of SiO2 particles. And thereby adsorption of water and ethanol molecules increased resulting to degree of swelling.

membrane-science-technology-SA-degree-swelling

Figure 5: Effect of mass ratio of TEOS to SA on the degree of swelling of hybrid membranes (12 μm).

Pervaporation performance

TG and DSC analysis: In general, the diffusion of pervaporation process plays an important role in permeate flux and the diffusion is influenced by membrane thickness. Table 2 illustrates that the permeate flux decreased with increasing membrane thickness. That’s because the increased mass transfer resistance led to reduced diffusion rate. The upstream side of the membrane was swollen and plasticized due to adsorbed liquid molecules and allowed unrestricted transport of feed components [26]. However, the downstream side of the membrane was dry in vacuum condition, which allowed smaller sized molecules to pass through. It’s notable that the water content of permeate side was nearly 100wt%.

Membrane Thickness(µm) Flux(g·m-2·h-1) Water content in permeate
10 274 99.95
15 248 99.96
20 169 99.96
26 137 99.94

Table 2: Influence of membrane thickness on pervaporation performance (SA-40 membrane, 10 wt% water in the feed, 50ºC).

Effect of mass ratio of TEOS to SA: As shown in Figure 6, Tables 3 and 4, the generated SiO2 particles can improve the roughness of membrane surface, and the permeability is influenced by membrane roughness. Pervaporation experiment was carried out to study the effect of mass ratio of TEOS to SA on the dehydration performance of 10 wt% water in the feed at 50°C. The membrane thickness was 12 μm. Figure 7 demonstrates that the permeate flux increased with increasing mass ratio of TEOS to SA. The permeate flux increased from 225 to 282 g-m-2.h-1 when the mass ratio increased from 0% to 60%. This is mainly due to increased interaction between water molecules and membrane. The free-volume in membrane matrix increased because of generated SiO2 particles [27]. The water content of permeate side was nearly 100wt% when the mass ratio of TEOS to SA was lower than 30% and decreased slightly over 30%. It may be that the interaction between water molecules and membrane matrix becomes weak because of slight agglomeration of SiO2 particles.

Membrane T(°C) Flux(g·m-2·h-1) Separation factor Reference
PVA-SA/PS 45 384 384 [5]
NaAlg-zeolite beta 50 166 465 [8]
NaAlg-zeolite beta 30 132 1598 [8]
CS-TEOS 80 284 460 [18]
NaAlg-mPTA10 50 393 2423 [29]
NaAlg-mPTA10 30 316 8991 [29]
SA- heteropolyacid 30 570 14991 [11]
SA-40 30 189 7013 This study
SA-40 50 274 17990 This study
SA-60 50 282 4496 This study

Table 3: Comparisons of pervaporation performance for dehydration of ethanol/ water mixtures with 10 wt% water in the feed.

Membrane Increase in surface area (%) Surface roughness(Ra)
(nm)
SA 0.59 3.63
SA-10 1.19 11.33
SA-20 2.88 112.82
SA-30 3.50 63.34
SA-40 0.76 31.68
SA-60 9.36 90.81

Table 4: The increase in surface area and surface roughness of SA and hybrid membranes calculated by AFM.

membrane-science-technology-surface-images-hybrid-membranes

Figure 6: AFM surface images of hybrid membranes: SA(a), SA-10(b), SA- 20(c), SA-30(d), SA-40(e), SA-60(f).

membrane-science-technology-SA-pervaporation-properties

Figure 7: Effect of mass ratio of TEOS to SA on the pervaporation properties (10 wt% water in the feed, 50ºC, 12 μm).

Effect of feed temperature: Effect of feed temperature ranging from 30°C to 50°C on the PV performance for water-ethanol mixtures was studied using SA-40 membrane at 10wt% water in the feed, and the results are presented in Figure 8. It’s observed that the permeate flux increased with increasing feed temperature which can be explained by solution-diffusion mechanism. With the increase of temperature, the vapor pressure difference increased between the upstream and downstream side of the membranes, which resulted in the enhancement of the driving force of transport. Higher temperature leads to higher molecular diffusivity [28]. Permeation of diffusing molecules pass through the membrane becomes easier, therefore, the mass transport is faster and the total flux increases. What’s more, as the temperature increased, the thermal mobility and the free volume of polymer were elevated, which led to the increase of the solubility of solution on the surface [29,30]. Meanwhile, the activation energy for permeation through the membrane can be described by Arrhenius relationship in Eq. (4).

membrane-science-technology-Effect-feed-temperature

Figure 8: Effect of feed temperature on pervaporation performance (SA-40 membrane, 10 wt% water in the feed, 12 μm).

image (4)

Where J is the permeate flux, J0 is the pre-exponential factor, EP refers to the activation energy for permeation, R and T are the gas constant and the operating temperature, respectively. Figure 9 was the normalized Arrhenius plot. From Figure 9, the activation energy for permeation through the SA-40 membrane was calculated from the slope of the fit liner and its value was 15.1 kJ/mol [30].

membrane-science-technology-permeate-flux-feed-temperature

Figure 9: Arrhenius relationship between permeate flux and feed temperature (SA-40 membrane, 10 wt% water in the feed, 12 μm).

Effect of feed water composition: Feed water composition exhibits a considerable effect on membrane performance. Figure 10 shows the permeate flux against the feed water composition of ethanol/water system, and the SA-40 membrane was used. The total flux increased from 161 to 985 g-m-2.h-1 with increasing water content in the feed. This can explain that an increase of feed water concentration may lead to enhancement of membrane swelling. The surface of the membrane became more compact, which led to a positive impact on flux.

membrane-science-technology-feed-pervaporation-performance

Figure 10: Effect of water content in the feed on pervaporation performance (SA-40 membrane, 50ºC, 12 μm).

Comparisons with literature data: The present PV data compared with former results provided by other researchers are listed in Table 3. It shows that the SA-40 membrane had higher separation factor with good permeate flux for separation of ethanol-water mixtures compared to similar data published in the literature.

Conclusions

The SA-Silica hybrid membranes were fabricated using solgel method for pervaporation dehydration of ethanol aqueous solution. The XRD characterization and SEM images indicated that SiO2 inorganic particles were generated by in situ hydrolysis and condensation of tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS) within SA aqueous solution. The thermal stability of hybrid membranes was improved after incorporating TEOS into SA. The tensile strength of SA-40 membrane was enhanced compared to SA membrane. The permeate flux was improved after incorporating TEOS into SA matrix. When the mass ratio of TEOS to SA was 40%, permeate flux reached 274 g-m- 2.h-1 while the water content of permeate side was nearly 100wt% with separation factor 17990.

Acknowledgements

This work was financially supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 21576132), National Key Science and Technology Program of China (No. 2013BAE11B01), Jiangsu Province Foundation of China (No. 2013- XCL-027).

References

Citation: Han S, Na S, Li W, Xing W (2016) Development of High Water Selective Sodium Alginate-Silica Hybrid Membranes via Sol-gel Technique for Pervaporation Dehydration of Ethanol. J Membra Sci Technol 6:165.

Copyright: © 2016 Han S, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.